The Electoral College: Mechanics and Controversies
Core Concepts
A detailed look at how the Electoral College works, from the allocation of electors to the winner-take-all system and its impact on presidential elections. This stack covers the fundamental rules, key terminology, and historical context necessary to understand this unique American institution.
The Electoral College: Mechanics and Controversies
1 of 14
What is the Electoral College?
The body of electors established by the U.S. Constitution, constituted every four years for the sole purpose of electing the president and vice president of the United States. Voters choose electors pledged to a particular candidate, not the candidate directly.
How is the number of electoral votes for each state determined?
Each state's number of electoral votes is the sum of its number of U.S. Senators (always \(2\)) and its number of U.S. Representatives in the House. This is why the census, which determines House apportionment, is so important.
What is the total number of electoral votes, and how many are needed to win the presidency?
There are a total of \(538\) electoral votes. A candidate must win a majority, which is \(270\) votes, to become president.
The \(538\) total electoral votes come from what sources?
The total is comprised of \(435\) votes from the House of Representatives, \(100\) votes from the Senate, and \(3\) votes granted to the District of Columbia by the 23rd Amendment.
Explain the "winner-take-all" system used by most states in the Electoral College.
In \(48\) states and D.C., the candidate who wins the state's popular vote is awarded all of that state's electoral votes, regardless of the margin of victory.
Which two states do not use the winner-take-all system, and what method do they use?
Maine and Nebraska use the Congressional District Method. They award two electoral votes to the statewide popular vote winner and one vote to the popular vote winner in each congressional district.
What happens if no presidential candidate receives the required \(270\) electoral votes?
The election is decided by the House of Representatives in a "contingent election." The House chooses from the top three electoral vote-getters.
How does the House of Representatives vote in a contingent election?
Each state delegation gets one single vote, regardless of the number of representatives it has. A majority of states (\(26\)) is needed to win.
Define "swing state" (or "battleground state").
A state where both major political parties have a reasonable chance of winning its electoral votes. Presidential campaigns focus their time and resources disproportionately on these states.
What is a "faithless elector"?
An elector who does not vote for the presidential or vice-presidential candidate for whom they had pledged to vote. They are rare and have never changed the outcome of an election, and many states have laws to prevent them.
What was the main change instituted by the 12th Amendment?
It separated the Electoral College vote for president and vice president. Previously, the candidate with the most votes was president and the runner-up was vice president, which led to the problematic 1800 election.
Identify one argument in favor of keeping the Electoral College.
Proponents argue that it protects the influence of smaller-population states, promotes a two-party system, and requires candidates to build broad, national coalitions rather than just focusing on high-population areas.
Identify one argument against the Electoral College.
Opponents argue that it is undemocratic because the popular vote winner can lose the election, it depresses voter turnout in "safe" states, and it gives disproportionate power to voters in small states.
How does the Electoral College system influence campaign strategy?
Candidates concentrate their resources, advertising, and campaign appearances in a handful of competitive swing states, while largely ignoring safe states where the outcome is predictable.
